Crest of the Royal National Institution of Naval Architects - Click to return to the homepage


Air Products_March 2021


International Registries April 2021

Cyber Security 2021


Cadmatic April 2021

Sea Spark April to July 2021


Paper Title: An Integrated Fuzzy MCDM Model For Evaluation And Selection of A Suitable Tugboat



A Balin, Istanbul University, Turkey

B Şener, Yildiz Technical University, Turkey

H Demirel, Zonguldak Bülent Ecevit University, Turkey


Tugboats are of vital importance in ports where a significant portion of world trade takes place. Selection of a tugboat that suitable for different operations in a port is a challenging problem that requires many different criteria to be evaluated at the same time. This selection requires high experience as well as technical knowledge of the tugboats and the operations to be carried out. In the present paper, an integrated model for evaluation and selection of tugboats is given. Based on the statistical data available in the study, assessment of the effect of different criteria on different harbour tugboats categorized according to the propulsion systems were carried out. The criteria for the tugboat alternatives were assessed through a questionnaire by subject-matter-experts containing comparative technical, financial and operational questions. The weights of each criteria were calculated using fuzzy Shannon’s entropy and fuzzy TOPSIS was utilized to rank the alternatives. Finally, the most suitable tugboat according to propulsion system was selected.



Transactions RINA, Vol 161, Part A3, International Journal Maritime Engineering, Jul - Sep 2019 

DOI Number

DOI No: 10.3940/rina.ijme.2019.a3.542A

Search and Order IJME papers

All International Journal of Maritime Engineering (IJME) papers are listed in the RINA Publications Database. You can search the database by author name and paper title. Publications may be ordered and paid for online. Other publications are also listed, some of which may be downloaded free of charge. Follow the link to Search Publications & Order.

RINA membership


Lloyds Academy March 120x120

Teinbridge Propeller


NRG Sonihull April 2021

Metstrade April 2021

Cyber Security Button 2021