Crest of the Royal National Institution of Naval Architects - Click to return to the homepage



Marintec_New_July_December 2022


Palfinger August 2022

IJME 277

Paper title: Hazard Identification and Probablistic Scenario Selection for Ship-Ship Collision Accidents



S A M Youssef, Y S Kim and  J K Paik, Department of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, Pusan National University, Busan, Korea
F Cheng, Lloyd’s Register, London, UK
M S Kim, Lloyd’s Register Asia, Busan, Korea 


In collision risk-based design frameworks it is necessary to accurately define and select a set of credible scenarios to be used in the quantitative assessment and management of the collision risk between two ships. Prescriptive solutions and empirical knowledge are commonly used in current maritime industries, but are often insufficient for innovation because they can result in unfavourable design loads and may not address all circumstances of accidents involved. In this study, an innovative method using probabilistic approaches is proposed to identify relevant groups of ship-ship collision accident scenarios that collectively represent all possible scenarios. Ship-ship collision accidents and near-misses recently occurred worldwide are collated for the period of 21 years during 1991 to 2012. Collision scenarios are then described using a set of parameters that are treated individually as random variables and analysed by statistical methods to define the ranges and variability to formulate the probability density distribution for each scenario. As the consideration of all scenarios would not be practical, a sampling technique is applied to select a certain number of prospective collision scenarios. Applied examples for different types of vessels are presented to demonstrate the applicability of the method.


Transactions RINA, Vol 156, Part A1, International Journal Maritime Engineering, Jan-Mar 2014 

DOI Number

DOI No: 10.3940/rina.ijme.2014.a1.277

Search and Order IJME papers

All International Journal of Maritime Engineering (IJME) papers are listed in the RINA Publications Database. You can search the database by author name and paper title. Publications may be ordered and paid for online. Other publications are also listed, some of which may be downloaded free of charge. Follow the link to Search Publications & Order.

RINA membership

Teinbridge Propeller

Euronaval Apr - Oct 2022

Herbert Engineering

Uni Stratchclyde June 2021

Metstrade May 2022