IJME - Reviewers' Comments & Recommendations Enter not this field: PAPER DETAILS Paper Title: Paper number [IJME XXXX]: ABSTRACT RATING Does the Abstract provide a meaningful and accurate representation of the paper?:* Yes No Where No, please comment: PAPER RATING [1 = Fails by a large amount and 4 = Succeeds by a large amount] The subject addressed in the paper is worthy of publication:* 1 2 3 4 The information presented in the paper is new:* 1 2 3 4 The paper dequately reviews and takes account of current literature:* 1 2 3 4 The conclusions are supported by the data:* 1 2 3 4 The paper is written with clarity of thought and expression:* 1 2 3 4 ASSESSMENT Strengths and weaknesses of the paper:* RECOMMENDATION Recommendation:* Publish as presented Publish subject incorporation of comments Do not publish REVIEWER'S DETAILS Name:* Financial or professional association with the author:* Yes No If yes, give details: *Indicates a field you must enter. When you have completed the form, please click the Send Details button ONCE to send Send Details Reset
